Browse All Suttons Bay MI Historical Properties for Sale

1917764 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

One of a kind fully-leased commercial and residential building with a beautifully built restaurant, multiple wine tasting rooms, retail and office spaces, and four successful airbnb rentals totaling over 18,000 square feet! With a full bar and (class C) liquor license, commercial kitchen, food and beverage store/market, indoor and outdoor seating for up to 300, and space for on-site brewery and event barn, the potential in this property is huge. No additional licensing is needed for a full brewpub operation with beer and wine takeout! Set on 4.3 acres with lengthy frontage on highly-traveled M-22, this building is just across the street from West Grand Traverse Bay including a popular public waterfront park and boat launch! There are beautiful bay views from many spots on the property, on the covered, 3-season, 1700+ square foot wrap around porch and in the building. The existing building is beautifully restored but also has value add potential, including a possible barn event space and two development parcels on the south side of the building - great possible brewery production building or additional residences. Ample parking, covered outdoor seating, and meticulous landscaping add to the phenomenal setting. Seller financing is a possibility - this property and opportunity are like no other in the Traverse City region!

5046 S West Bay Shore, Suttons Bay

$675,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1917271 MLS ⋅ Village of Suttons Bay BLDG.

Nostalgic village home features a wrap around covered porch and secluded back yard for your outdoor enjoyment. Renovated in 2015, the new compliments the touch of the old -- claw foot tub, multi-pane interior French doors, etc. A master bedroom with private baths can be found on both the main and upper levels! Located app. 2 blocks from the public school and 2 blocks from restaurants and shopping.

219 W Madison, Suttons Bay

$450,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1917172 MLS ⋅ Metes and Bounds BLDG.

Vintage 1920’s Leelanau County farm house. Every square inch is curated with the perfect eclectic décor. This property features much of the original trimwork and doors, wood floors throughout. 2 bedrooms and 2 baths. Enormous master suite with bedroom sized sitting area (or nursery or den.) It could easily be a 3 bedroom. Over sized two car garage. Cavernous dining and kitchen with premium appliances (including Viking range.) The setting is just over one acre that borders the Leelanau TART trail. Two story garden storage/playhouse with balcony is ready for your finishing ideas.This property can be used as a short term rental.

3509 S Center Highway, Suttons Bay

$250,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1916872 MLS ⋅ Stone Schoolhouse BLDG.

Located in the heart of Suttons Bay and only 20 minutes from Traverse City, this unfinished 2 bed/2.5 bath condo sits within the historic Union Schoolhouse- built in 1906 and comprised of stacked local fieldstone 3 feet thick, this property is a true Northern Michigan treasure. This unit features a sunken foyer entry and steps up into the main living space, awaiting your dreamiest customizations!

513 N Saint Marys Street Unit 5, Suttons Bay

$820,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1916662 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.

Nestled in the heart of the picturesque Village of Suttons Bay, this breathtaking craftsman-style home is a sanctuary of elegance, comfort, and pure serenity. Welcome to your dream home! The heart of the home features a Carrera marble island that's as beautiful as it is functional. Vaulted ceilings and cherry wood counters create a sense of timeless beauty. Top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances cater to your culinary passions. Elevate your entertaining game with a butler's pantry that adds elegance and convenience to every gathering. A 2-sided gas fireplace is the perfect companion for chilly Michigan nights, ensuring warmth and ambiance. Beamed ceilings, antique heart pine floors, and shiplap-accented walls add character and warmth to every corner of this home. No need to worry about power outages; this home is equipped with a whole house Generac generator to keep you comfortable no matter the weather. For pet lovers, an invisible pet fence ensures the safety and freedom of your furry family members. Nestled along the back of the property, a tranquil stream flows, creating an ambiance of peaceful serenity. With a gazebo that beckons you to unwind, this outdoor oasis is perfect for morning coffee or evening stargazing. One of the unique advantages of this property is that it's within walking distance of the charming Suttons Bay Village & community beach. You can enjoy the local shops, restaurants, and the beautiful bay with ease.

372 S Shore Drive, Suttons Bay

$725,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1915765 MLS ⋅ Herman’s 1st Add to Suttons BLDG.

Enjoy Suttons Bay living in This beautiful 3Bd 2Ba home. Plenty of room to stretch out with its large meticulously maintained lot. A complete remodel in 2004/2005 included a spacious main floor layout, family room addition, masonry gas fireplaces, and finished lower level. This home is ready for you to bring vision and make it your own. Located just a stone's throw from everything that Suttons Bay has to offer.

205 S Elm Street, Suttons Bay

$99,000

1914723 MLS ⋅ none BLDG.

Established pizza, sandwich and salad restaurant in great downtown Suttons Bay location on M22 across from Boone’s and close to Leelanau Trail bike path. Excellent traffic/visibility, with parking both in front and to the rear. Additional revenue from arcade/party room. Available turnkey with all kitchen equipment (including hood vent) and arcade games included (see personal property list). Outdoor seating area includes partial bay view. Good opportunity to further enhance revenue. Seller will assist with business transition. For business/personal property only, real estate not included, and includes assumption of lease.

100 S Cedar Street, Suttons Bay

$859,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1913084 MLS ⋅ Village of Suttons Bay BLDG.

LOCATION x 3 - located in the popular vacation land of Leelanau County & Village of Suttons Bay. Updated Victorian Beauty walking distance to beach, restaurants, shops. 5 bedroom 2602 sq. foot home with 2022 NEW Designer kitchen high end appliances, cabinetry, updated HVAC, electrical, ducted heating & A/C, fireplace, original wood floors, pocket doors/molding, gas fireplace - charm galore. Unique home has an INDOOR SWIMMING POOL in south facing wing. The pool wing provides an extra 1400 +sq. feet of useable space (finished drywall/skylights/slab) - use as is or convert to pickleball court, game room, or living space. "Mancave" above garage adds another 350+ sq. feet of functional space. 1750+ extra sq. feet of bonus space overall. Front porch swing, courtyard dining, and secluded back yard (+ shed for beach garden storage - or even converted children's "playhouse"). This house provides endless space for gatherings or privacy. Staycation possibilities are endless with this property.

209 N Saint Marys, Suttons Bay

Start Your Search

Suttons Bay Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Suttons Bay and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!